Local ACLU Defends Data Critical of the Grossmont Union HS District

David Loy stands by report that 41 percent of Grossmont ELL students received no services.

The legal director of the local ACLU is defending the data used to accuse the Grossmont Union High School District of failing to provides services to 1,300-plus English learner students.

After the Grossmont district issued a statement blaming a state reporting error in an American Civil Liberties Union report, David Loy of the ACLU of San Diego & Imperial Counties told Patch: “The numbers we cited derive from data reported to the state by school districts themselves, including GUHSD.”

Loy said that when districts such as GUHSD report that large numbers of English language learning (ELL) students are receiving no ELL services, “the state has a legal duty to investigate and determine whether necessary services are not being provided or whether the report derives from a reporting error, as GUHSD states, and then follow up to ensure the problem does not recur.”

He added via email Friday: “The state should have been asking those questions long ago.”

Last week, in a letter to state officials critical of many school districts, the ACLU said 41 percent of Grossmont ELL students were receiving no services—1,389 out of 3,368 students.

The district called the numbers “false and reflects a data reporting problem. … GUHSD will work with the California Department of Education to better align our data to CDE’s classifications.”

The 1,389 ELL students in question were proficient enough to be enrolled in mainstream English classes, the district said.

Asked whether Grossmont had a response to Loy’s remarks, spokeswoman Catherine Martin on Wednesday said no.

“The [Jan. 24] statement stands as our response,” she said via email.

Karen Cadiero-Kaplan, director of the California Department of Education’s English Learner Support Division, a week ago issued a statement regarding media coverage of the ACLU report.

“Despite the enormous financial strains of recent years, California has made dramatic progress in seeing that all English learners receive appropriate instruction and services,” Cadiero-Kaplan said.

She said school districts report that more than 98 percent of the state’s 1.4 million English learners are receiving services.

“The [Education] Department has yet to see or review the claims made [Jan. 23], although it is noteworthy that a previous action by some of the same parties was recently dismissed with no adverse finding against the CDE,” she said.

A recent Court of Appeal decision affirmed that the department and the state schools superintendent “had fulfilled their legal obligations related to on-site monitoring of English learners,” she said.

Even so, her statement concluded: “The department encourages any parents concerned about the instruction of their children to work with their local school district and, if necessary, make use of the department’s complaint process to resolve any concerns.”

For the ACLU’s part, Loy said, “The problems we detail transcend any individual district. We are looking for a statewide solution to a statewide problem, in compliance with the state’s legal obligations.”

Things I Learned February 01, 2013 at 08:21 AM
Hey remember when the ACLU used to defend people like the guy who's in jail because he made a movie that inconvenienced his majesty Barack Obama (PBUH) and now they defend data that the people who made the data say is wrong but when your press release says Ima sue you what choice do you have hey look Illinois Nazis I do?
Komfort February 01, 2013 at 04:31 PM
Did the movie guy release a sequel? http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/report-injured-blast-us-embassy-18374304 Obama "decimated" al Qaeda so we can't blame him.
Harry Jones February 03, 2013 at 12:27 AM
Think I'd quite going out of my way to force schools to give classes in language other than english. Most 2rd 3rd 4th generation Ameircans relatives had to learn hard way to speak english. OJT... They helped win 1st 2nd WW, invented great tihngs etc etc. These Americans I'm proud of, not those who sit back & expect me to provide everything thru taxes.... If you don't want to learn or even try to learn, pack your bags & go home. Not other countries ewven offer training/learn. In Japan it's eithert sink or swim. Your choice. Let's see what you're made of..


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »